As a major Danish funder of technical and natural science research carried out at Danish research institutions, Villum Foundation has a strong wish to keep improving its grant making processes and explore novel approaches to research assessment.
The Villum Experiment programme, offered annually since 2017, targets unorthodox research ideas in their early phase. The proposals are evaluated anonymously to ensure a focus on the research idea only. The latest call may be consulted here.
For the past five years the Danish Centre for Studies in Research and Research Policy has conducted an initial study on the outcome of the Experiment programme, exploring issues such as gender differences, writing styles and the use of the reviewers’ ‘golden tickets’ (see list of published papers below). As citation data accumulate it becomes possible to explore more wide-ranging questions, including whether the outcome and impact (appropriately defined) from the Villum Experiment projects funded so far differ from those of more conventional grant schemes.
Villum Foundation invites applications for ambitious and innovative studies of the outcome of the Villum Experiment programme, going beyond the initial study and preferably building on its results. The foundation will provide successful applicants with a unique data set including granted and rejected proposals submitted to the programme between 2017 and 2025.
Applications may be made for financial support of up to 5 MDKK, including indirect costs (cf. below). Projects may last up to four years. The foundation expects to be able to fund up to two projects.
For the assessment, we will be trialling distributed peer review in combination with a committee evaluation. Distributed peer review is a review process in which applicants are asked to act as reviewers for the call. This approach has been used by a number of funders in recent years, and in the present call Villum Foundation wishes to gain experience with this mode of reviewing.
The primary applicant must be an internationally recognized, permanently employed researcher at a Danish or European public research institution within the field of Research on Research. In the context of this call, European means based in an EU member state, or in Norway, Switzerland or the UK.
The foundation welcomes collaborative proposals spanning more than one research group. However, the application is submitted by a single principal investigator, and the entire grant is administered by their home institution.
Successful applicants will – subject to signing a data agreement with the foundation – gain access to a data set containing full texts of approx. 3700 applications submitted to the Villum Experiment programme between 2017 and 2025, as well as information on applicants, assessment panels and assessment results. Final reports from finished projects will also be available. Access will be given on condition that only aggregate results, not attributable to specific applicants or applications, are published in the outcomes of the project.
The applications will be assessed by the Villum Foundation working group for technical and natural science, based on the following criteria:
Applications will be subject to distributed peer review. Each applicant will be required to review up to five applications from the call. By submitting an application to this call you confirm that you will carry out the reviewing in a fair, balanced and timely way. Failure to do so will impact negatively on your own application.
Applicants will receive the peer reviews in anonymized form and will get the opportunity to reply to them.
The final recommendation to the board for rejection or approval will be made by our Working Group for Technical and Natural Science, based on the applications, the peer reviews and the reply to the peer reviews.
If granted the project should start 1 January 2027 at the latest.
The submission must contain the following documents in pdf format, submitted as four separate files:
The application should include:
You may apply for up to 5 million DKK, including indirect costs.
Eligible budget items include:
The salary of permanently employed scientific staff is not eligible for support.
Villum Foundation is a party to the agreement between a number of private foundations and the Danish universities on a common model for indirect costs. This means that for projects carried out at a Danish university, indirect costs are covered through a project supplement calculated from the number of project-funded full-time academic staff equivalents in certain staff categories. The project supplement is DKK 250,000 per project-funded full-time academic staff equivalent in eligible staff categories.
Below you may find links to the papers from the initial study on the Villum Experiment programme conducted by Danish Centre for Studies in Research and Research Policy at Aarhus University.
Print the necessary guidelines before applying.